hans

The Omnifarium - Politics/LindaKeen.html

Linda Keen Strikes Back

Category: Politics
Tue, 29 Jan 2008, 14:44

"When it comes to nuclear facilities, ignoring safety requirements is simply not an option, not now, not ever." Linda Keen at a House committee meeting on the shutdown of the Chalk River nuclear reactor.

Do politicians know more about nuclear safety than the former head of Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission? That is, should we leave nuclear safety to politicians instead of people who are expert in the field? Of course not! And yet we have a situation where Canadian politicians of all parties voted to restart the Chalk River nuclear reactor against the advice of the experts.

What about those of us who live near other nuclear reactors, such as the eight at Pickering? Will politicians make the decisions regarding the operational safety of these reactors too? I hope not! But they've clearly shown that they're not above putting politics ahead of science.

It's gotten even more silly now: Opposition parties that voted for restarting the Chalk River reactor are now calling for a public inquiry on Linda Keen's dismissal!

Certainly an inquiry is a good idea. But more importantly, that reactor at Chalk River should be shut down until the required safety improvements are implemented. Keen reports one in a thousand odds for an accident at Chalk River, one thousand time worse than international standards. That's unacceptable even in other less serious engineering domains. That is, do you want one in a thousand odds of an accident while driving your car? Or using a power tool?

Or should we start electing scientists as our members of parliament, instead of lawyers and economists?

By the way, there was a great editorial cartoon in a local newspaper a couple of weeks ago. The scene is Stephen Harper's office. His secretary is bringing in the new nuclear safety watchdog, Homer Simpson! I don't think I laughed at that cartoon.

Hans

path: /Politics | permanent link to this entry

friendship